News writer
What happens when someone decides lottery tickets are easier to steal than to win?
Two Red Oak, Iowa, residents may have found out Tuesday afternoon when police arrested them in connection with a sprawling theft operation. The charges paint a picture of systematic fraud: over 500 stolen lottery tickets and roughly $1,600 in profits.
The arrests
Police took Jessica Andrea Nunez, 22, and Kaleb Rylie Toepher, 21, into custody around 3 p.m. Tuesday in the 400 block of North 3rd Street. The investigation involved both the Red Oak Police Department and the Iowa Lottery Authority.
Nunez faces two felony counts of lottery ticket theft and two counts of 2nd-degree theft. Toepher was charged as an accessory after the fact for the ticket thefts, plus 2nd-degree theft for the money obtained from the stolen tickets.
Bond was set at $5,000 for each suspect. Both were held at the Montgomery County Jail.
The scale of the scheme
Five hundred lottery tickets don't disappear by accident. This wasn't someone pocketing a few scratch-offs on impulse. The investigation uncovered a pattern suggesting deliberate, repeated theft over time.
The profit margin tells its own story. After stealing more than 500 tickets, the pair allegedly netted about $1,600. That works out to roughly $3 per ticket, a reminder that lottery tickets rarely pay out, even for thieves.
How did authorities catch on? The Iowa Lottery Authority tracks ticket inventory and can flag unusual patterns. When hundreds of tickets go missing from a location, the system notices.
What comes next
Both suspects now face serious charges. Second-degree theft in Iowa is a Class D felony, punishable by up to five years in prison. The lottery ticket theft charges carry their own penalties, designed specifically to deter this type of fraud.
These aren't the first Iowans accused of targeting the lottery system. But they're far from the most sophisticated.
A much bigger lottery heist in Iowa
The Red Oak case pales in comparison to Iowa's most infamous lottery scandal. Eddie Tipton, head of IT security at the Multi-State Lottery Association, rigged lottery games across nearly three dozen states starting around 2005. He installed self-deleting software that reduced millions of possible winning combinations to just a few hundred on three specific dates each year. When he tried to claim a $16.5 million Hot Lotto jackpot in 2010, security footage and his distinctive voice gave him away.
Tipton was sentenced to up to 25 years in prison and ordered to pay $2.2 million in restitution. He served approximately five years before being released on parole. The scandal destroyed public trust in the Hot Lotto game, forcing the Multi-State Lottery Association to discontinue it entirely in 2017. A new documentary, "Jackpot: America's Biggest Lotto Scam," premiered on YouTube and exposes how the man responsible for protecting lottery security became its biggest cheater.
The moral of the story
Stealing lottery tickets might seem like a shortcut to easy money. But as both the Red Oak case and the Tipton scandal prove, lottery theft investigations are thorough, and consequences are severe. The Iowa Lottery Authority tracks every ticket, and modern security systems make it nearly impossible to steal without getting caught. Whether you steal 500 tickets or rig the entire system, the house always finds out, and the odds are never in your favor.
Comments