All news

Michigan trio's lottery scam hits a dead end in South Dakota

The suspects tried their luck with fake payments, but store employees weren't fooled, and arrests soon followed.

The Codington County Detention Center in Watertown, South Dakota.
The Codington County Detention Center in Watertown, South Dakota, where the three suspects of this lottery scam are being held pending further proceedings. Photograph credit to Google Maps.
Todd Betzold

Winning the lottery is all about luck — but for three Michigan suspects, their so-called "winning strategy" landed them in handcuffs instead of a jackpot. Authorities say the trio attempted a scam at multiple gas stations, using a sneaky payment trick to score hundreds of dollars in lottery tickets.

Their first attempt failed, but just minutes later, they struck gold — at least until police showed up. Now, with arrests made and cash seized, investigators are warning businesses to stay alert for similar fraud.

Two attempts — one success

The suspects reportedly tried two times in their lottery scam, with employees stopping them on their first attempt. However, they were successful in their second attempt just minutes later.

On February 10, 2025, a store manager in Watertown, South Dakota, was notified by the store's corporate office that a scam took place in Fargo, North Dakota. For that alert, images of the suspects and their vehicle were released.

That same day, a person at a Watertown gas station called the Watertown Police Department regarding a fraud case.

According to authorities, the suspects tried to make a fraudulent transaction in Watertown, but the store employees denied them. Just minutes later, another report came in from another gas station in Watertown. However, this time, those same individuals were successful in using fraudulent credit card information to buy $700 worth of lottery tickets.

How did the lottery scam work?

So, how were these suspects able to purchase the South Dakota Lottery tickets using fraudulent credit card information? The suspects allegedly presented a card that appears to be legitimate. However, it required special instructions on the back of the card, which told cashiers to process the transaction as a cash sale — this would falsely show a completed payment.

Suspects arrested

Police officers in Watertown were able to quickly respond to the location and found the three suspects near the gas station. A search of the suspects and police said they found about $2,000 in cash and multiple prepaid debit cards.

While the fraudulent transactions took place in Watertown, the trio of suspects were from Michigan. One of the suspects, a 19-year-old from Flint, Michigan, was arrested and charged with identity theft, conspiracy to commit a felony, fraudulent use of a credit card, organized retail crime, and possession of a controlled substance.

The two other suspects were also from Flint and were arrested on similar charges. The police said the other two suspects were 18 years old and 20 years old.

All three of the suspects were booked into the Codington County Detention Center pending further proceedings.

Police are warning other businesses in the area to be on the lookout for these fraudulent-type transactions and to report any suspicious activity to police.

Lottery theft in Georgia

Cops in Georgia were also busy arresting a suspect accused of stealing Georgia Lottery tickets from a convenience store in Senoia. Authorities started investigating the robberies when a store manager reported shortages in their lottery funds.

The shortages took place on January 26 — $120 short — and January 28 — $75 short. Officials obtained security footage from those days and observed two individuals enter the store on both dates, with one of the suspects reaching behind the counter and grabbing some high-value lottery tickets before leaving the store.

Police said the suspect, who was recognized on security footage by the store manager, took four $30 tickets on January 26 and three $25 tickets on January 28.

On February 11, Kentaevius Render, 26, turned himself into the police and was charged with two counts of theft by shoplifting.

Enjoy playing the South Dakota Lottery, and please remember to play responsibly.

Comments

0
Loading comments

Related articles

Parker's #94, located at 230 Church Street in Georgetown.
Woman charged with lottery fraud over a scratcher worth just $25

Investigators say she took the scratcher while on the job and then cashed it in at another location.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Main Stop convenience store in Pioneer, Ohio.
Woman who set fire to cover lottery theft finally admits guilt

A Toledo woman admitted guilt in an $89K lottery theft scheme.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

The Texas Lottery Commission deliberating about the banning of lottery courier services in the state.
Unregulated & unstoppable: Lottery couriers operate in legal gray areas

As lottery apps proliferate across the U.S., the Texas scandal exposes the dangerous gap in regulations.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

On the left, security footage that allegedly shows Samantha Young stealing tickets over the counter. On the right, Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd showing Samantha's picture during a morning briefing.
Scratch, steal, go to prison: Lottery ticket thieves exposed

These thieves tried to cash in stolen lottery tickets.

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer

Recent articles

View All
Parker's #94, located at 230 Church Street in Georgetown.
Woman charged with lottery fraud over a scratcher worth just $25

Investigators say she took the scratcher while on the job and then cashed it in at another location.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Rhode Island Numbers logo over a blue background with dollar signs.
Why 1-2-3-4 just made thousands of Rhode Islanders rich

Sequential numbers just paid out nearly 500% across Rhode Island.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

An EuroMillions playslip.
Winner hits biggest jackpot in EuroMillions history

Irish luck? An unidentified player in Ireland takes home 250 million Euros.

Halley Bondy profile pic

Halley Bondy

The Florida Lottery Pick 3 logo, along with the number 666.
Florida Lottery draws 6-6-6, but it's all luck for Pick 3 winners

Is the universe playing tricks? One of the most feared numbers just brought in nearly $2 million.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold