All news

Man steals lottery tickets at gunpoint, gets caught cashing in winners

A man hoping for an instant win got an instant arrest after police traced the stolen tickets back to him.

Mark Schnyer.
Mark Schnyer; charged with first-degree robbery, larceny, and threatening charges after stealing Connecticut Lottery tickets at gunpoint. Photograph credit to the Torrington Police.
Todd Betzold

It turns out that stealing lottery tickets isn't exactly a winning strategy — especially when those tickets come with easily traceable serial numbers. A Connecticut man learned that lesson the hard way after allegedly threatening a gas station clerk with a gun and making off with nearly $1,000 worth of scratch-off tickets.

But his so-called jackpot run didn't last long. Within two hours, police had tracked him down, thanks to the very tickets he stole. Now, instead of cashing in, he's facing a different kind of payout — criminal charges and a hefty bond.

Clerk threatened with a gun

Around 7:20 p.m. ET on the night of the incident, police were called to a Citgo gas station located on North Elm Street in Torrington in regards to a panic alarm that was set off. Once at the gas station, a clerk told police that a man, later identified as 25-year-old Mark Schnyer, walked into the store and used a self-scanning machine to check some lottery tickets for winners. Authorities said there was no indication whether any of those tickets scanned were winners.

After scanning the tickets, Schnyer allegedly showed the clerk a firearm and forced the employee to give him more of the similar $50 tickets he just scanned. Police said the clerk gave him a total of nearly $1,000 worth of the Connecticut Lottery scratch-off tickets.

According to the arrest warrant obtained by The Register Citizen, the victim told police that the suspect showed him a black handgun that was sticking out of his right pants pocket and threatened to shoot him if he didn't give him any tickets. The victim gave Schnyer the tickets, and then he left the store.

Police did talk to a witness that night, and they told police that the weapon the suspect used was a BB gun.

Working with the state's Gaming Commission

After realizing the suspect had made off with lottery tickets, authorities contacted the state's Gaming Commission to identify the missing ticket numbers. Police were able to determine that the first six winning tickets out of tickets Schnyer stole, which were worth $100 each, were cashed at a location on East Main Street later that same night.

Schnyer reportedly tried to redeem more winning tickets at another location, but he wasn't able to because the store clerk said there wasn't enough cash in the register, police said.

An arrest was quickly made

The police wasted no time in arresting Schnyer. They were able to track him down when he showed up at Cumberland Farms on South Main Street at 9:18 p.m. ET that same night, so less than two hours after they were called to the first gas station for the panic alarm.

They were able to track him down so quickly because of the serial numbers on the winning tickets.

Schnyer was booked into jail and charged with first-degree robbery, larceny, and threatening charges. He was being held on a $200,000 bond, officials said.

Enjoy playing the Connecticut Lottery, and please remember to play responsibly.

Comments

0
Loading comments

Related articles

Lea Rose Fiega, with her $1 million check from the Massachusetts Lottery.
Million-dollar trash: These lottery players almost threw away jackpots

How a homeless man almost trashed a $4 million lottery ticket, and other stories of dumpster jackpots.

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer

North Carolina college students participate in a career fair on campus.
Why record lottery sales no longer guarantee record school funding

A surge in ticket buying masked a quieter shift in payouts, profits, and where the lottery's dollars end up.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

Lottery balls on a lottery machine.
Five predictions for the lottery in 2026

Why 2026 could be the most consequential year in modern lottery history.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

Florida Lottery winner Leonard Linton, with his $2 million check and his faithful companion Ivy.
These lucky pets helped their owners score major lottery jackpots

Can a lucky spider or pet make you a lottery millionaire?

 

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer

Recent articles

View All
Murphy USA gas station in Cabot, Arkansas, a small town outside of Little Rock.
Featured
Everything we know about the $1.82 billion Powerball winner

Who took home the second-biggest lottery jackpot of all time?

Halley Bondy profile pic

Halley Bondy

A table with various tax related forms and items.
Lottery winners face major tax shift under 2026 legislation

What every lottery winner needs to know before claiming their prize in 2026.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

The image of a Georgia Millionaire and Minnesota Millionaire Raffle ticket, along with the logo for the Pennsylvania New Year's Millionaire Raffle.
Lottery fireworks: Raffles deliver big wins to start 2026

Players in three states rang in the new year with $1M wins, as the first day of 2026 brought massive wins.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

Lea Rose Fiega, with her $1 million check from the Massachusetts Lottery.
Million-dollar trash: These lottery players almost threw away jackpots

How a homeless man almost trashed a $4 million lottery ticket, and other stories of dumpster jackpots.

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer