All news

Lottery tickets stolen in smash-and-grab incident; suspect arrested

Breaking glass, stolen tickets, and a fast arrest — Connecticut police connect the dots to solve the case.

Aric McCray, 53, of New Haven.
Aric McCray, 53, of New Haven, charged with third-degree burglary, sixth-degree larceny, and third-degree criminal mischief. Photograph credit to the Waterbury Police Department.
Todd Betzold

A quiet morning in Connecticut recently took a chaotic turn when an alarm at a local store signaled trouble. By the time police arrived at the store in Waterbury, the culprit had already vanished, leaving behind shattered glass and making off with a peculiar prize — non-activated Connecticut Lottery tickets.

However, the story didn't end there. Later that same morning, an unexpected twist led authorities to a man whose luck had clearly run out.

Early morning break-in

Around 4:45 a.m. ET on January 3, 2025, officers from the Waterbury Police Department responded to a report of an alarm going off at Winner's, located at 155 Thomaston Avenue in Waterbury.

Once at the sportsbook location, police confirmed that a burglary had occurred. Authorities said a male suspect used a rock to break the store's glass and gain entry into the building.

However, the suspect was able to flee the scene on foot before police arrived, but not before he allegedly took non-activated lottery tickets.

What are non-activated lottery tickets?

Before any scratch-off lottery tickets make their way into a kiosk or ticket holder at a lottery retailer, the pack of tickets has to be activated. The tickets arrive at lottery retailers unactivated and must be activated before they are put out for sale.

This is done to prevent situations like the one mentioned above. A person is unable to steal a whole book of tickets and then turn around and try to cash in the winners. If the tickets are non-activated, the winning tickets from that book cannot be redeemed for cash.

A quick arrest

Authorities wasted no time in making an arrest in this theft case. Later that morning, around 10:00 a.m. ET on January 3, members of the Gang Task Force and the State Police Violent Crimes Task Force were conducting a separate investigation when they observed a man matching the description of the robbery suspect from Winner's.

Police identified the suspect as Aric McCray, 53, of New Haven. He was then taken into custody and initially charged with trespassing and possession of drug paraphernalia, officials said.

Upon further investigation, police said McCray was also charged with third-degree burglary, sixth-degree larceny, and third-degree criminal mischief. He remains in custody of the Connecticut Department of Corrections and is being held on a $110,000 bond.

This isn't McCray's first run-in with the law, as he has a history of burglary arrests and convictions and he currently has six pending cases in New Haven.

Activated and winning

The Connecticut Lottery recently announced that it is continuing its partnership with the University of Connecticut Division of Athletics. With that partnership, the Lottery announced they would be launching a new $5 scratch-off ticket called UConn Championship Cash.

This $5 ticket has more than $3.5 million in total cash prizes and three top prizes of $50,000. Players will also have the opportunity to win tickets to attend select men's and women's basketball games through social media, TV, and radio promotions.

One lucky player wasted no time taking home one of those top prizes, either. The tickets were activated and ready for purchase, and lottery officials said Nicole had tried her luck and won $50,000. She told lottery officials she beat cancer last year, so she was excited to kick off 2025 with a big win that left her feeling blessed.

Enjoy playing the North Carolina Lottery, and please remember to play responsibly.

Comments

0
Loading comments

Related articles

The Huron County building where the 52nd Judicial Circuit Court operates is where Ruben Whimper entered his guilty plea.
Man pleads guilty to using stolen credit cards to buy $7K in lottery tickets

From Bad Axe to Battle Creek, this lottery scam stretched far, but justice caught up fast.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

A police car with their flashing lights.
Knife pulled in lottery fight over winning ticket

Police say the lottery ticket wasn't the only thing these men had on them. What else turned up during the arrest?

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Hitt the Road in Arimo, where the alleged theft of scratch-off tickets took place.
Convenience store employees accused of scratching without paying

Police say a quiet repayment deal turned into felony charges after over $5,000 in scratch-offs went missing.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

A courthouse during a trial.
Jackpot justice: How lottery officials stole millions

This lottery official stole tickets worth nearly $500,000.

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer

Recent articles

View All
Weis Markets in Spring Township.
Big win in the Keystone State: Cash 5 player scores $400,000

Unknown winner hits the big one in Pennsylvania's oldest jackpot game.

Halley Bondy profile pic

Halley Bondy

The Huron County building where the 52nd Judicial Circuit Court operates is where Ruben Whimper entered his guilty plea.
Man pleads guilty to using stolen credit cards to buy $7K in lottery tickets

From Bad Axe to Battle Creek, this lottery scam stretched far, but justice caught up fast.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

A New Jersey Lottery sign promoting CASH POP.
Local games thrive as Mega Millions and Powerball sales fall

Despite $3.3B in sales, the New Jersey Lottery faces a player revolt against impossible jackpots. Is this the future?

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

The $792,900 winning Michigan Fantasy 5 ticket.
Michigan woman on July 4 camping trip wins jackpot

The winner checked her ticket while camping to find a $792,900 surprise.

Halley Bondy profile pic

Halley Bondy