All news

Fake lottery ticket leads to home invasion and $27K jewelry theft

Harlem woman, 79, loses thousands after lottery scam leads to home robbery.

The two suspects that the NYPD is searching for in relation to the theft of $27,500 from a 79-year-old Harlem woman.
The two suspects that the NYPD is searching for in relation to the theft of $27,500 from a 79-year-old Harlem woman. Photograph credit to the NYPD.
Samantha Herscher

A 79-year-old Harlem woman lost $27,500 in jewelry and cash after falling victim to a lottery ticket scam that ended in a home invasion. The brazen crime reveals how far scammers will go to exploit elderly New Yorkers.

How the Harlem scam unfolded

Two suspects approached the victim near West 138th Street and Broadway around 11 a.m. ET on May 2. They presented what appeared to be a winning lottery ticket and convinced her they would share the earnings.

The woman agreed to the arrangement. That's when the situation turned violent.

The suspects threatened to assault her and forced her to take them to her residence. Once inside, they stole jewelry and cash worth approximately $27,500 before fleeing eastbound on West 137th Street.

The suspects 

The NYPD released surveillance footage showing both suspects walking with the victim:

  • Suspect 1: Male wearing a black medical mask, blue baseball hat, white jacket, gray pants, and black sneakers.
  • Suspect 2: Female wearing a gray medical mask, brown bucket hat, brown jacket, blue jeans, and multicolored sneakers.

This isn't an isolated incident

Just two months earlier, a similar scam targeted an elderly Bronx woman. Four men executed a coordinated attack on March 20 near 845 White Plains Road, stealing $17,700 in jewelry from an 80-year-old victim.

The Bronx operation showed sophisticated planning. Two suspects distracted the victim with a fake lottery ticket while their accomplices moved in to steal her jewelry. The level of coordination suggests these criminals may have performed similar scams throughout the city.

Why elderly New Yorkers become targets

Criminals prey on excitement about sudden good fortune. They understand that the prospect of easy money can create momentary distractions, making victims vulnerable to theft. Elderly residents often become prime targets because they may be more trusting or less likely to recognize modern scam tactics.

What authorities are doing

The NYPD has classified both cases as grand larceny. Investigators are reviewing surveillance footage from nearby businesses and have increased patrols in affected areas.

The 43rd Precinct boosted patrols around Soundview locations frequented by senior citizens following the Bronx incident.

How you can help

Do you recognize any of these suspects? The NYPD offers rewards of up to $3,500 for information leading to arrests in both cases.

Contact Crime Stoppers at 1-800-577-TIPS or submit information anonymously through their website.

Protecting yourself

Is someone approaching you with an unexpected windfall? Here's what you need to know to protect yourself from lottery scams:

  • Legitimate lottery winnings require official verification. Real lottery tickets must be validated through authorized retailers or official lottery offices.
  • Strangers don't share winnings with random people. Why would someone split the money with you instead of keeping it all?
  • Trust your instincts. Does the situation feel too good to be true? It probably is.
  • Never go anywhere with strangers. No legitimate lottery winner needs you to accompany them anywhere.

Stay alert, question unexpected offers, and never let excitement override your better judgment.

Comments

0
Loading comments

Related articles

Nick Perry and his lawyer, Thomas Livingston, giving a press conference after the trial.
The Kingpins of Keystone: Pennsylvania's underground lottery empire

How illegal lotteries helped pay for the Pittsburgh Steelers.

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer

Parker's #94, located at 230 Church Street in Georgetown.
Woman charged with lottery fraud over a scratcher worth just $25

Investigators say she took the scratcher while on the job and then cashed it in at another location.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Main Stop convenience store in Pioneer, Ohio.
Woman who set fire to cover lottery theft finally admits guilt

A Toledo woman admitted guilt in an $89K lottery theft scheme.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

The Texas Lottery Commission deliberating about the banning of lottery courier services in the state.
Unregulated & unstoppable: Lottery couriers operate in legal gray areas

As lottery apps proliferate across the U.S., the Texas scandal exposes the dangerous gap in regulations.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

Recent articles

View All
The Jersey Cash 5, Nebraska Pick 5, and Palmetto Cash 5 logos over a pink background with golden stars.
Five-number draw games score jackpot wins in 3 states on the same night

From $180K to $472K, players in Nebraska, New Jersey, and South Carolina are a whole lot richer.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Michigan Lottery Super Raffle logo over a black background.
Michigan Lottery launches biggest raffle prize in history

Michigan Lottery's $6 million Super Raffle returns with premium $50 tickets targeting high-roller players.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

Parker's #94, located at 230 Church Street in Georgetown.
Woman charged with lottery fraud over a scratcher worth just $25

Investigators say she took the scratcher while on the job and then cashed it in at another location.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Rhode Island Numbers logo over a blue background with dollar signs.
Why 1-2-3-4 just made thousands of Rhode Islanders rich

Sequential numbers just paid out nearly 500% across Rhode Island.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher