All news

Double the luck: Couple wins lottery twice in one day

Playing birthdays turned into double delight for an Ohio couple, who scored $25K and more just in time for the holidays.

Ohio Lottery Pick 5 game logo
Todd Betzold

Winning the lottery is a dream come true — but twice in one day? That’s exactly what happened to a couple in Ohio, who turned their lucky streak into a double dose of holiday cheer.

After months of playing their family birthdays in the Ohio Lottery’s Pick 5 draw game, Randy and Tanya Metzger scored not one but two winning tickets on the same day. With big plans for their winnings, the Metzgers are proving that sometimes lightning does strike twice.

Back-to-back wins

The Metzgers have been playing their birthdays in the lottery’s Pick 5 drawings for the past nine months. Good luck finally arrived for them during the December 3, 2024, evening Pick 5 drawing.

After the drawing took place, the couple noticed they hit for $417 on one ticket where they chose the $1 box option. The winning numbers for that draw were 9-4-7-5-1.

Randy told lottery officials, “I never look at the other ones. When I go and get them for the next day, I scan them.”

So, Randy had no clue what was about to happen when he stopped by Speedway #3187, located at 746 W. Harding Way in Galion. He just planned on turning in his one winning ticket, but he got some shocking news when he scanned the other one.

He told lottery officials, “It said, ‘$25,208.50’ and I go, ‘what?’ and then I looked and thought, ‘those are the same numbers.’”

The Metzgers matched the winning numbers for the Pick 5 midday drawing, which happened to be 7-5-3-6-0 for that December 3, 2024, drawing. While the couple used their birthdays for the other winner, this winning ticket was an auto pick and played as a backup.

Claiming their prize

The Ohio couple headed to lottery headquarters to collect their winnings. After the mandatory state and federal taxes totalling 28 percent were withheld from the $25,208.50, they took home approximately $18,150.12.

With their winnings, the couple told officials they were planning on paying off their car and then making Christmas merrier for several people who are in need.

Another holiday winner

With the holidays right around the corner, another Ohio Lottery player has reason to celebrate the season.

Michelle, the lucky winner, took home the top prize playing the $10 scratch-off game called Winter Fun. She purchased the winning ticket at Meijer Gas #189, located at 1961 W. Clinton St. in Defiance.

She recently made her way to lottery headquarters to claim her prize. After mandatory state and federal taxes totaling 28 percent, Michelle took home about $360,000.

After her big win, there are now two more top prizes of $500,000 remaining to be claimed in the Winter Fun game. In addition, there are two $100,000 prizes remaining in the game, as well as six $50,000 prizes and 12 $10,000 prizes available. The prizes for Winter Fun range from $10 up to the top prize of $500,000.

Enjoy playing the Ohio Lottery, and please remember to play responsibly.

Comments

0
Loading comments

Related articles

Suspect identified as 24-year-old Christian Nasir Nelloms. Photo credit: Palm Beach County Jail.
Florida man wins the lottery, then gets jumped before he can celebrate

Police say surveillance shows the attacker waiting in the shadows long before the assault.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

An image showing a paper representation of a family being broken up.
Tragic wins: Lottery jackpots that broke families

Big lottery wins tore these families apart.

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer

Letters on a table spelling "Thank you" with Christmas ornaments surrounding it.
8 things lottery players are thankful for in 2025

This holiday season, lottery players are counting their blessings from $1B jackpots to funds for schools.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

Fired envelope
How a $20K ticket created one of Tampa’s weirdest lottery disputes

A loyal friend, a scratcher win, and a pointed memo collided into a messy dismissal. Why?

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

Recent articles

View All
Technology shaping future of lottery
How tech-savvy players are shaping the future of the lottery

From online tickets to automated services, players are setting the pace. Could this reshape how we all play?

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

West Davidson High School
Can lottery funds keep schools safe and standing in North Carolina?

From safety tech to infrastructure fixes, the request shows how essential lottery revenue has become.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

Powerball jackpot growing graph
No winner yet: Powerball jackpot climbs to $875 million

Monday's Powerball prize is the seventh-largest jackpot in lottery history.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

Suspect identified as 24-year-old Christian Nasir Nelloms. Photo credit: Palm Beach County Jail.
Florida man wins the lottery, then gets jumped before he can celebrate

Police say surveillance shows the attacker waiting in the shadows long before the assault.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold