All news

How a $20K ticket created one of Tampa’s weirdest lottery disputes

A loyal friend, a scratcher win, and a pointed memo collided into a messy dismissal. Why?

Fired envelope
Todd Betzold
Add lotteryusa.com as a preferred source on Google

A city official in Tampa, Florida, has been fired after prosecutors suggested he played a role in helping a lottery winner sidestep $70,000 in unpaid child support. However, those same prosecutors also declined to file charges against the same city official.

A firing triggered by a scratch-off

Keith O’Connor, the former director of code enforcement for the city and former deputy chief at the Tampa Police Department, was fired this week after the Hillsborough County State Attorney’s Office released a memo outlining their concerns regarding his involvement with a $20,000 winning ticket from the Florida Lottery.

In a statement to FOX 13, O’Connor’s attorney, Ralph Fernandez, blasted the memo for being a targeted hit. He said, “This memo is a hatchet job. I’m surprised people still do this.”

The scratch-off scandal

According to this memo, the winner, Aubrey Pierce, had a long history with O’Connor. They used to work together at a city trash disposal site. O’Connor reportedly was instrumental in helping Pierce find a job and get some stability in his life after multiple arrests.

That is when Pierce found himself with a winning scratch-off ticket, which Lottery USA previously reported. Prosecutors said at that time, Pierce owed tens of thousands in past-due child support.

Investigators determined that Pierce gave the ticket to O’Connor, and he claimed the winnings. Prosecutors wrote in the memo that this created a reasonable “presumption” that giving the ticket to O’Connor was an attempt to hide the winnings from the state.

“This is an example of what the state strongly believes happened versus what it can actually prove in court,” the memo states.

However, Fernandez says the exchange was innocent, with Pierce being grateful to O’Connor. 

"Pierce never had two nickels to rub together," said Fernandez. "He gets his ticket, and he says, 'You know what? I want you to have it, and whatever.' Once that transaction is completed, even if it takes one second, O'Connor can do whatever he wants with that money and give it back to Pierce to buy equipment for a side job."

However, prosecutors said in the memo that Pierce allegedly told others he had someone else cash the ticket to avoid garnishment. They said this type of conduct was “suggestive of theft,” though not provable.

No charges, but consequences

The memo stated the evidence failed to establish wrongdoing “beyond a reasonable doubt.” Because of that, no charges were filed against O’Connor.

However, Tampa’s mayor’s office deemed O’Connor’s judgment to be poor enough that it would merit immediate dismissal.

While addressing whether or not O’Connor could have avoided the appearance of improper behavior, Fernandez told FOX 13, “Every human being that faces a difficult encounter regrets being in that position to any extent.”

Meanwhile, prosecutors defended writing the memo, saying it helped show transparency and explained why no charges were filed.

A controversial history overshadows the case

This lottery scandal gained further attention because of O’Connor’s high-profile connection: his wife. She is Mary O’Connor, the former Tampa Police Chief.

Mary resigned from her position in 2022 after a now-infamous incident took place in which she flashed her badge during a golf traffic stop in Pinellas County. During that stop, she asked deputies to “just let us go.”

Fernandez argued that this memo served as the political push certain officials needed to remove O’Connor after the prior scandal put the couple under heightened scrutiny.

Garnishments in Florida

This story revolves around the $20K lottery ticket. In Florida, lottery winnings are considered income for child support enforcement. So, if a player owes past due support, then a portion of those winnings can be automatically garnished to pay off the debt.

For Florida Lottery players, the key takeaway is clear (which O’Connor appeared to know about): any outstanding child support obligations could affect your winnings. Attempting to sidestep these rules and payments could result in legal trouble.

Enjoy playing the Florida Lottery, and please remember to play responsibly.

Comments

0
Loading comments

Related articles

The Millionaire for Life logo over a background with golden sparks.
Big September change coming to Millionaire for Life prizes

These new rules would make the game's $100,000-a-year prize much harder to keep as a lifetime annuity.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

A picture of police cars with their lights on.
Three lottery crimes, three states, one warning for players

From stolen scratch-offs to a $15,000 scam, recent cases show how lottery schemes take many forms.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Hoosier Lottery logo along with a picture of the $5 Space Invaders Cash Invasion scratch-off ticket.
Indiana Lottery's Space Invaders glitch leaves players out $100K

The ticket said $100,000. The Lottery said otherwise.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

Tammy Carvey of Wyandotte, Michigan, claims ChatGPT picked her winning Powerball numbers.
Why do people think AI can help them win the lottery?

This lottery player claims AI helped them win $150,000. Is it true?

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer

Recent articles

View All
A Michigan Lottery Lotto 47 ticket on top of other lottery tickets.
Featured
The math behind Lotto 47

Michigan's Lotto 47 has more layers than its $1 price tag suggests. Here's what the numbers reveal.

Dr. Catalin Barboianu profile pic

Dr. Catalin Barboianu

The Millionaire for Life logo over a background with golden sparks.
Big September change coming to Millionaire for Life prizes

These new rules would make the game's $100,000-a-year prize much harder to keep as a lifetime annuity.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Massachusetts Lottery Megabucks logo over a yellow background with shooting stars.
How high can it go? Megabucks crosses the $20M mark

The game has gone over a year without a jackpot winner, fueling a historic run to the third-largest jackpot.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Connecticut Lottery logo over a white background.
Connecticut uses lottery equipment for tax reform panel

How a lottery ball could reshape Connecticut's property taxes.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher