All news

Judge says lottery theft case against Nebraska man can move ahead

He cashed in the $300K winning ticket, but court docs say he broke the rules to do it.

Jeremiah Ehlers.
Jeremiah Ehlers is facing one count of felony theft after allegedly scratching a winning Nebraska Lottery scratch-off ticket before paying for it. Photograph credit to the Lancaster County Department of Corrections.
Todd Betzold

It all started as a feel-good lottery win for a gas station manager in Nebraska. However, it has unraveled into a legal battle involving surveillance video, seized bank accounts, and felony charges.

Now, the $300,000 prize the manager once celebrated is at the center of a case that a judge ruled could move forward. It's bringing attention to the case of how one ticket could cause such a mess.

The judge makes his ruling

It has been a long road, but a case against a gas station manager accused of stealing a winning Nebraska Lottery scratch-off ticket took a step forward on Wednesday.

On May 28, 2025, Lancaster County Judge Joseph Dalton ruled there was enough evidence to try 50-year-old Jeremiah Ehlers, and his case was sent to the district court. Ehlers is facing one count of felony theft by deception.

The big win — or was it?

The Nebraska Lottery celebrated a $300,000 win in April 2024 from its Diamond Dollars scratch-off game. The lucky winner was a gas station manager from Greeley named Ehlers.

According to lottery officials, Ehlers purchased the winning ticket at Greeley Rapid Stop, where he worked. Ehlers told lottery officials he had been scratching some lottery tickets with a coworker the night before, but they didn't have any success.

So, he returned to work the next morning and wanted to try his luck, so he claims he bought a $30 ticket and hit the jackpot. He scanned the winning ticket two or three times to make sure before jumping in his car and heading to Lincoln on April 12, 2024, to claim his big winnings. He left lottery headquarters with $213,000 after taxes.

But suspicions surfaced

However, suspicions started to surface just 11 days later. On April 23, 2024, the owner of Greeley Rapid Stop contacted lottery officials, claiming Ehlers had stolen scratch-off tickets while he was working.

As previously reported by Lottery USA, Ehlers could be seen on surveillance footage grabbing a Diamond Dollars ticket without paying. He then scratched it off, scanned it twice, and then he can be seen paying for it.

Nebraska law states all tickets must be paid for before they are played. However, the sequence of events by Ehlers violated that rule.

Court documents state:

Ehlers created a false impression to the store, the public, and the Nebraska Lottery.

During the investigation, authorities went through surveillance footage from March 30 to April 19. Investigators saw Ehlers make 29 legitimate sales to the public during that time. He was also seen on two separate occasions receiving tickets from a coworker before he paid for them.

The money moved fast

Ehlers didn't mess around after receiving the winnings. He quickly deposited the money into his bank account.

Authorities would later seize $128,769.31 from his bank accounts. However, they claimed Ehlers had already spent the rest of the money — around $84,000 — on two vehicles, contractor services, and paying off some debts.

After a months-long investigation, officials issued a warrant for Ehlers' arrest on January 3, 2025. Police took him into custody on January 27, and he was charged with felony theft by deception for more than $5,000 in Lancaster County.

Judge Dalton scheduled Ehlers' arraignment in Lancaster County District Court on June 25.

Enjoy playing the Nebraska Lottery, and please remember to play responsibly.

Comments

0
Loading comments

Related articles

Nick Perry and his lawyer, Thomas Livingston, giving a press conference after the trial.
The Kingpins of Keystone: Pennsylvania's underground lottery empire

How illegal lotteries helped pay for the Pittsburgh Steelers.

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer

Parker's #94, located at 230 Church Street in Georgetown.
Woman charged with lottery fraud over a scratcher worth just $25

Investigators say she took the scratcher while on the job and then cashed it in at another location.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Main Stop convenience store in Pioneer, Ohio.
Woman who set fire to cover lottery theft finally admits guilt

A Toledo woman admitted guilt in an $89K lottery theft scheme.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

Recent articles

View All
The Jersey Cash 5, Nebraska Pick 5, and Palmetto Cash 5 logos over a pink background with golden stars.
Five-number draw games score jackpot wins in 3 states on the same night

From $180K to $472K, players in Nebraska, New Jersey, and South Carolina are a whole lot richer.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Michigan Lottery Super Raffle logo over a black background.
Michigan Lottery launches biggest raffle prize in history

Michigan Lottery's $6 million Super Raffle returns with premium $50 tickets targeting high-roller players.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

Parker's #94, located at 230 Church Street in Georgetown.
Woman charged with lottery fraud over a scratcher worth just $25

Investigators say she took the scratcher while on the job and then cashed it in at another location.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Rhode Island Numbers logo over a blue background with dollar signs.
Why 1-2-3-4 just made thousands of Rhode Islanders rich

Sequential numbers just paid out nearly 500% across Rhode Island.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher