All news

Clerk threatened, tickets taken — police say the suspect used a fake gun

The plan? Walk in, fake a gun, and leave with tickets. The outcome? Jail time and a court date.

A police officer in New Castle, Pennsylvania.
Todd Betzold

It wasn't a winning ticket that got one Pennsylvania man noticed — it was the way he allegedly tried to get it. In the early morning hours, a trip to a Turkey Hill convenience store turned into a lottery heist involving threats, a fake gun, and more than $600 worth of stolen scratch-offs. But as one man gambled with the law, another was cashing in on a jackpot the legal way and being celebrated for it.

Threats with a fake gun

Around 3:30 a.m. EST on June 11, 2025, a Hanover Township man allegedly threatened a Turkey Hill clerk in Exeter while he stole over $600 worth of Pennsylvania Lottery tickets. Officers with the Wyoming Valley Regional Police said the suspect, later identified as 31-year-old James Robinson, pretended to have a gun and warned the clerk not to interfere.

Around 1:00 p.m. EST on June 11, 2025, authorities said they identified Robinson on the corner of a street in Exeter.

Robinson was taken into custody and charged with robbery, theft, and other associated offenses. He remains in jail on a $50,000 bond.

Lottery officials celebrating

While Robinson was put behind bars for his alleged attempt to win a big jackpot, another Pennsylvania man was being celebrated by lottery officials after his big online win. Officials held a check presentation ceremony at the Lottery Area Office in Pittsburgh recently to give the winner his $1.35 million prize.

Christopher Lehman of Beaver County, an active-duty member of the Army for 25 years, was the lucky winner. He won $1.35 million playing the Jackpot Spectacular online game on May 30.

Lehman told lottery officials:

My wife always says I have good luck. I looked at the progressive prize amount for Jackpot Spectacular and thought, 'That one's about to pop soon.' I budgeted $100 to play that day. I figured if I lose, I lose.

He did not lose, and his intuition that the progressive jackpot was about to pop came true. Lehman recalled:

The bonus popped up, and I couldn't believe it. I just stared at it for a second. My wife didn't believe it either. We called the lottery together, and I put the phone on speaker so we could both hear it was real.

Lehman actually won on the same day he signed up for an online Pennsylvania Lottery account. He just moved to the state from New Hampshire, so he was trying his luck in his new state. Secretary of Revenue Pat Browne said:

Congratulations to Christopher and his family on winning this life-changing prize. We're also reminding everyone that every lottery purchase, whether online or in-store at a retailer, helps the Pennsylvania Lottery fulfill its mission of supporting programs and services that benefit older Pennsylvanians. We're proud that this win not only changes one life, but also contributes to making a positive difference for seniors in communities across the Commonwealth.

Now that he has his winnings in hand, Lehman said he and his plan on paying off their mortgage and his wife's car loan and then investing the rest. His youngest daughter is also graduating from Army basic training on June 12, so they're excited to travel there to celebrate her accomplishment.

Enjoy playing the Pennsylvania Lottery, and please remember to play responsibly.

Comments

0
Loading comments

Related articles

Some packaged gifts, Mega Millions tickets, a cup with coffee, glasses, a tie, and formal shoes on top of a blue surface.
Seven gift ideas for lottery-loving dads on Father's Day

Father's Day is coming. Consider these lottery-related gifts he'll actually use.

Halley Bondy profile pic

Halley Bondy

The New York Police Department logo over a white background.
Lottery ticket scam resurfaces — NYPD urges New Yorkers to stay sharp

Someone claims they can't cash their lottery ticket and need your help? The 71st Precinct says walk away fast.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

James Farthing with his $167.3 million Powerball check.
Big winner's big change: From not guilty to serving time

Kentucky Powerball winner initially pleaded not guilty to charges but is now requesting to serve out his sentence.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

Osceola County Sheriff Marcos Lopez.
Florida sheriff arrested in high-stakes illegal gambling case

Authorities say the sheriff protected the business, which took in $21.6 million before the bust.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

Recent articles

View All
Some packaged gifts, Mega Millions tickets, a cup with coffee, glasses, a tie, and formal shoes on top of a blue surface.
Seven gift ideas for lottery-loving dads on Father's Day

Father's Day is coming. Consider these lottery-related gifts he'll actually use.

Halley Bondy profile pic

Halley Bondy

A calendar with the Mega Millions logo and a marking on Friday the 13th.
Can Friday the 13th be lucky again? $264M jackpot up for grabs

Some call it cursed, but Friday the 13th has delivered millions in Mega Millions winnings. Could this be your turn?

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Montana Millionaire logo over a yellow background.
Montana Millionaire gets a makeover with five $1 million prizes in 2025

Officials scramble to add 120,000 more lottery tickets after unprecedented demand.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

Petry's Bait Company, located at 2220 Highway 18 in Finlayson, Minnesota.
Finlayson's fortune: Small town bait shop sells $1.16M winning ticket

Petry's Bait Company produced Minnesota's newest Gopher 5 millionaire last night.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher