All news

Police arrest screwdriver-wielding robber in lottery ticket heist

Police say the repeat offender returned mid-robbery to grab more lottery tickets and flee in a getaway SUV.

Rafael Rodriguez, charged by the Mahwah Police Department with armed robbery, aggravated assault, theft, and weapons offenses after a lottery heist.
Rafael Rodriguez, charged by the Mahwah Police Department with armed robbery, aggravated assault, theft, and weapons offenses after a lottery heist. Photograph credit to the Mahwah Police Department.
Todd Betzold

A Bronx, New York man who was armed with screwdrivers and a bold plan turned a quiet Route 17 convenience store into the scene of a wild robbery. From demanding cigarettes to leaping on the counter for lottery tickets, the suspect left both the clerk and investigators scrambling for answers.

However, this wasn't just a random act. Police said it was a tag-team heist with an accomplice and an unusual getaway strategy.

The wild scene

Around 4:30 a.m. ET on November 21, 2024, Rafael Rodriguez entered the Bolla Market on northbound Route 17 near the New York state line in New Jersey, according to the Mahwah Police Department.

Mahwah Police Detective Lt. Kevin Hebert said Rodriguez initially entered the store and demanded cigarettes despite not having any money. He then left the store.

However, he returned shortly after, but this time wearing a “surgical-style mask, gloves, and a dark colored unbuttoned coat over the sweatshirt he was previously wearing,” police said.

Authorities said Rodriguez then grabbed multiple screwdrivers that were near the cash register and pointed them at the clerk. He then demanded cigarettes and money.

Rodriguez then reportedly jumped on the counter and started taking lottery tickets from a display case, Hebert said. The clerk tried stopping the man, but then Rodriguez “lunged at the clerk with the screwdrivers,” police said.

While all of this was taking place, police said a second male suspect walked into the store and took condoms and lottery tickets. Both of the suspects then left the store.

Not done yet

While the suspects did leave the store, it looked like they weren't quite done yet. The men stopped their blue Toyota Highlander with Connecticut plates at the exit to the highway.

From there, Rodriguez allegedly got out of the vehicle, walked back into the store, and took more lottery tickets. He then headed back out to the vehicle, and he and his companion sped off, police said.

One suspect was identified and arrested

Detectives conducted interviews and reviewed surveillance footage from the store. Investigators also collected other evidence from the scene, authorities said.

Based on that information, it didn't take long for them to identify and obtain a warrant for the arrest of Rodriguez.

Hebert said it was easy finding Rodriguez, as he was arrested by the New Jersey State Police in a separate incident. At that time, he was booked into the Middlesex County Jail.

On Wednesday, December 4, detectives with the Mahwah Police Department picked up Rodriguez from the Middlesex County Jail and brought him to their headquarters. He was charged with armed robbery, aggravated assault, theft, and weapons offenses and booked into the Bergen County Jail.

The search continues

While Rodriguez has been arrested and charged in connection with the robbery, his accomplice remains free.

Police said they are still searching for Rodriguez's companion, and anyone with information that could help identify and/or find him is asked to call the Mahwah Police Detective Bureau at 201-831-2020.

Enjoy playing the New Jersey Lottery, and please remember to play responsibly.

Comments

0
Loading comments

Related articles

A New York State Police car.
New York bar worker allegedly spent hours playing lottery on house tab

He reportedly cashed in over $4K in wins before the bar noticed the missing funds.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Texas Lottery logo over a white background.
How is the Texas Lottery performing after the transition to the TDLR?

A new boss, new rules, and still billions raised — the Texas Lottery isn't missing a beat.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Red Oak Police Department.
Red Oak duo charged in brazen lottery ticket theft scheme

The pair faces felony charges after 500 tickets were stolen.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

Recent articles

View All
A couple of sample tickets for the Maryland Lottery Holiday Raffle.
Maryland Holiday Raffle starts today with $1 million grand prize

Get them before they sell out: Maryland $1M Lottery Holiday Raffle launches today.

Halley Bondy profile pic

Halley Bondy

The screen of a lottery retailer system.
Millionaire for Life? The rumored new game might arrive in 2026

This proposed $5 lottery ticket could pay you $1 million every year for life.

Samantha Herscher profile pic

Samantha Herscher

A New York State Police car.
New York bar worker allegedly spent hours playing lottery on house tab

He reportedly cashed in over $4K in wins before the bar noticed the missing funds.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Mississippi Lottery Cash 3 logo over a yellow background with red and blue strikes.
Mississippi players can triple their Cash 3 wins in November

 This month, play Cash 3, win triple in Mississippi.

Halley Bondy profile pic

Halley Bondy